Can a stumble through a wrong door lead to Mr. Right? When Celeste McCarthy's parents announce plans to sell the family's cherished Butterfly Lake Lodge, she's devastated. She's grown up working at the lodge and hoped to build her career and life there. Her parents think the new owners will keep her on, but Celeste needs certainty, not hope. She enrolls in a local accounting class to boost her resume but ends up in a salmon fly tying course taught by a local angler, who's distractingly handsome. Jack Wallace is teaching the college extension class hoping to increase his fly fishing business that's been struggling since a media savvy trust fund kid moved to town, and hooked many new clients despite his inexperience fishing. Jack is intrigued enough by the beautiful Celeste that he steps out of his comfort zone and agrees to help her plan a groomsman day out for an influencer's wedding held at her lodge. As Jack and Celeste work side by side during the weekend wedding, they begin to discover that sometimes, the best catch is found in unexpected waters.